Is it worth reading Scarlett after Gone with the Wind? Or will the experience be spoiled?



Netping 2 pwr 220 v3 eth

The author posted a question in Arts Culture

Is it worth reading Scarlett after Gone with the Wind? Or will the experience be spoiled? and got a better answer

Response from

Response from 0[+++]
Sure you should.

Response from 0[+++++]
read it, I liked the sequel more than the first two books.

Response from 0[+++++]
It's worth reading, not watching, in the movie they made her into an alcoholic, and they couldn't describe her feelings. In general it is always more interesting to read.

Response from 0[++]
Of course you should, because in the movie the story is changed. I like the book better.

Response from 0[+++++]
You shouldn't. But if you ask, you'll read it anyway.

Response from 0[+++++]
The movie is good, but the novel itself is much more informative.

Response from 0[+++++]
It's worth it, it's worth it, I thought so too at first, but then I couldn't tear myself away.

Response from 0[+++++]
It might get spoiled, but how will you know if you don't read it. Take a chance! А!

Response from 0[+++++]
I can't speak for you. I'll tell you my opinion. it feels at once that another person wrote it. and I hated it. I can't imagine Scarlett like that. she couldn't be like that, if you compare her to the Scarlett described by Gone with the Wind.

Response from 0[++]
Taste and color, as they say. I liked it very much. But please don't read the following sequels about Scarlett - such nonsense!

Response from 0[+]
Worth it! You'll get a lot more impressions if you're not without imagination.

Response from 0[++]
Always worth reading the sequels to unfinished stories.

Response from 0[++]
Probably shouldn't - but you'll read it anyway. And in general you should not read the sequel written by another author - the idea is lost. I have after Gone with the Wind - left such a sense of elusiveness, you can think of something yourself. It is not for nothing the author has left room for us to flight of fancy. And so we'll think about it tomorrow.

Response from 0[+++]
I personally do not recommend the first part much better.

Response from 1yard[+++++]
Hi! Here is a selection of topics with similar questions and answers to your question: Is it worth reading Scarlett after Gone with the Wind? Or will the experience be spoiled?
Netping on Wikipedia
Check out the wikipedia article about Netping
 

To answer the question:

Name*

E-mail:*

Reply text:*
Verification code (enter 22):*